Paradyme™ 27GY STR System

Reducing PCR Stutter to Improve STR Interpretation

Anupama Gopalakrishnan, Senior Product Manager, Promega Corp., Madison, WI, USA

Share this article

ABSTRACT

Stutter artifacts are a persistent feature of PCR-based STR typing and remain a practical challenge in deconvolution of mixtures in forensic casework. While analytical thresholds and locus-specific stutter filters help manage these artifacts to some extent, interpretation complexity can increase when contributor ratios are imbalanced, DNA template is limited, or profiles are affected by inhibition or degradation. The Paradyme™ 27GY STR System (in development) incorporates a reduced-stutter DNA polymerase that minimizes the appearance of stutter artifacts. When integrated with Promega’s eight-color technology, which facilitates analysis of smaller loci, this new STR System delivers enhanced performance for challenging degraded and mixture samples. The Paradyme™ 27GY STR System is designed for use on Spectrum CE System or Spectrum Compact CE System.

WHY STUTTER STILL MATTERS IN EVERYDAY CASEWORK

Capillary electrophoresis (CE) STR typing has been used for decades, and most laboratories have well-established processes for setting analytical thresholds, applying stutter expectations, and interpreting common artifacts. Yet PCR stutter remains one of the most frequent sources of interpretive “noise,” especially in mixtures, where peaks from multiple contributors overlap or fall close together.

Stutter peaks are not random in location; they occur at predictable positions—usually one or more repeats smaller (minus stutter) or larger (plus stutter) than the real allele at positions where true low-level minor contributors may also reside. That predictability helps analysts—but it also

creates an interpretive paradox: the very place an analyst expects to see stutter is also where a true low-level minor allele may appear. As a result, stutter can contribute to both:

» False complexity (artifact peaks treated as allele candidates), and

» Missed information (true alleles discounted as stutter)

WHAT CAUSES STUTTER

Stutter is closely linked to strand slippage by DNA polymerase during PCR amplification of tandem repeat regions. During replication, the strands “slip” with respect to each other to create amplification products that are one or more repeat unit(s) shorter (or occasionally longer) than the true allele resulting in a characteristic set of minor peaks near the allele peak. Traditional mitigation is largely downstream comprising filters, interpretation rules, and probabilistic models.

INTRODUCING PARADYME™ 27GY STR SYSTEM

The Paradyme™ 27GY STR System is Promega’s fourth eight-color STR chemistry kit. The system includes 23 autosomal STR loci (including CODIS markers); the Y-STR loci DYS391, DYS570, and DYS576; the internal quality indicators QIS and QIL; and the gender marker Amelogenin and is designed for use on the Spectrum CE System¹ and Spectrum Compact CE System².

It contains a reduced-stutter polymerase that produces cleaner STR profiles by lowering stutter peaks, making low-level minor contributor alleles easier to see and interpretation more consistent with fewer stutter-overlap borderline calls.

Because the system uses shorter amplicons with all 20 expanded CODIS core loci below

375 bp—it increases the likelihood of generating informative profiles from degraded samples.

Paradyme™ 27GY STR System also contains two quality indicators, QIS and QIL, that provide context about amplification performance across samples. In practice, QIS/QIL peak height ratios can help differentiate scenarios such as globally reduced amplification due to inhibition, locus dropout patterns consistent with degradation, or low signal due to limited template. This can support more consistent decisions about reprocessing (e.g., additional cleanup, re-amplification, alternate input strategies) and improve communication about sample limitations.

Figure 1: Paradyme™ 27GY STR System loci layout

Figure 2: 0.5 ng of 2800M was amplified for 30 cycles with the Prototype reagents of Paradyme™ 27GY STR System. The amplified fragments were electrophoresed on the 8 capillary Spectrum CE instrument using 2 kV/18 sec injection and data was analyzed at 150 RFU AT (Analytical Threshold) using GeneMarker® HID Software for Spectrum CE Systems³.

MIXTURES: WHERE REDUCED STUTTER MAY HAVE THE LARGEST IMPACT

Mixture interpretation is where many labs spend disproportionate time—especially when the minor contributor is low-level or the contributor ratio is highly imbalanced. Under these conditions, stutter becomes more than a predictable artifact; it becomes a competing explanation for peaks near allele positions.

Reducing stutter at the chemistry level can improve mixture interpretation by simplifying the peak landscape that drives probabilistic genotyping models and the human review that accompanies them offering:

» Cleaner inputs for probabilistic methods: fewer artifact peaks competing with allele hypotheses

» More consistent analyst experience: reduced dependence on subjective judgment for borderline peaks

This can make the probabilistic genotyping more powerful as the likelihood ratios obtained for genotypes for minor contributors are likely to be higher than they would be if the same sample had been processed with stutter.

In Figure 3, an example at D8S1179 locus illustrates reduced stutter artifact peaks in a mock mixture when comparing a conventional STR chemistry to Paradyme™ 27GY STR System.

Shown is the D8S1179 locus from a mock casework mixture amplified with PowerPlex® Fusion 6C System4 (left) and Paradyme™ 27GY STR System (right). In conventional STR chemistries, stutter is not always removed by a stutter filter—for example, elevated stutter artifacts due to coincident plus and minus stutter can elevate a stutter peak above the locus-specific threshold (allele 13 in Figure 3), causing it to be treated as an allele during mixture deconvolution (false-

positive allele). Conversely, a true minor-contributor allele (allele 15 in Figure 3) may fall below the stutter threshold, leading to its inappropriate exclusion from deconvolution (false-negative allele). Reducing stutter can lessen both failure modes and support clearer allele calling.

Figure 3: Representative D8S1179 electropherograms from a mock casework mixture amplified with the PowerPlex® Fusion 6C System (left) and the Paradyme™ 27GY STR System (right). DNA was purified using the Maxwell® FSC DNA IQ™ Casework Kit⁵ on the Maxwell® RSC48 Instrument⁶ and quantitated with the PowerQuant® System⁷. Normalized template was amplified with the two STR Systems, electrophoresed on a 8 capillary Spectrum CE instrument and data analyzed using GeneMarker® HID Software for Spectrum CE Systems.

SUMMARY

The Paradyme™ 27GY STR System, currently in development, incorporates a reduced-stutter polymerase intended to limit stutter artifact formation and support cleaner electropherograms. The eight-color assay architecture enables smaller amplicons beneficial for degraded samples, and internal quality indicators that can provide additional context for interpreting inhibited and/ or degraded profiles.

REFERENCES

  1. Spectrum CE System, 8-Capillary Operating Manual
  2. Spectrum Compact CE System Operating Manual
  3. GeneMarker®HID Software for Spectrum CE Systems User Manual
  4. PowerPlex® Fusion 6C System for Use on the Spectrum CE System Technical Manual
  5. Maxwell® FSC DNA IQ™ Casework Kit Technical Manual
  6. Maxwell® RSC48 Instrument Operating Manual
  7. PowerQuant® System Protocol

ACKNOWLEDGEMENT

The author would like to thank Promega's Genetic Identity Research and Development team for their contributions to the development of the Paradyme™ 27GY System and also thank colleagues who provided technical feedback during preparation and review of this manuscript.

Image Header: Promega